August 9, 2020


Aim for Excellence

Misplaced Analogies: COVID-19 Is More like a Wildfire Than a Wave

New coronavirus bacterial infections have soared to their maximum concentrations in five states, as some...

New coronavirus bacterial infections have soared to their maximum concentrations in five states, as some leaders pause plans to reopen organizations more. The record highs—in Arizona, Florida, Georgia, Nevada, and South Carolina—mark a relating to increase in situations that is now stretching into its 3rd consecutive week. Far more than two.5 million people today in the United States have been contaminated with coronavirus and at minimum a hundred twenty five,000 have died, bigger than any other country.

Early in the pandemic, Sarah Cobey, an epidemiologist and evolutionary biologist at the College of Chicago, pivoted her possess study on influenza to model the dynamics of COVID-19. In this article she solutions some inquiries from Scientific American contributor Marla Broadfoot about why we are looking at an uptick in cases—and whether or not they herald a dreaded second wave of the ailment.

[An edited transcript of the interview follows.]

This month additional than 20 states have described a increase in day-to-day coronavirus situations. Is this uptick component of a 1st or second wave? Or are people types even a valuable way of looking at this pandemic?
I think this is a hard query, for the reason that I am not certain that it is that valuable to think about the dynamics that we are looking at as waves. We know that influenza and a lot of other respiratory pathogens bring about these wavelike epidemics, the place the crests and troughs of the waves are set by the portion of the populace that is prone. Epidemics start off declining when the prone populace falls beneath the threshold for herd immunity. And they can get off again once the prone portion rises earlier mentioned it. But what we are looking at here is a virus that of course has not been circulating in a populace for a extended time—and to which most of us are nonetheless prone. There is no purpose that we really should be looking at the sort of wavelike epidemic dynamics that we have observed for other respiratory pathogens. Alternatively what we are looking at is a enormous epidemic that could melt away by the populace fast unless we do one thing to gradual transmission, which is what we are at this time undertaking with interventions these as social distancing and masks. It is feasible that, about time, COVID-19 could start off establishing cyclical, flulike waves. But that is decades away.

If we had been to use the wave terminology that is in prevalent parlance, what sorts of dynamics with the ailment really should we expect to see following?
We could see all different forms of resurgences or waves. And it really depends on what we do. We could have just 1 big wave like Japan, which appears to be to be handling the virus very nicely, if we adhered to comparable interventions right up until a vaccine is designed. We could see one thing like a second wave if people today just gave up entirely, for instance, on social distancing or wearing masks. But I do not think that is consistent with our conduct.

Some professionals and politicians have instructed the new coronavirus could possibly die down in the summertime. Yet new situations are nonetheless on the increase. Do these latest trends notify us anything about the seasonal nature of the pathogen?
Most respiratory viruses that have been examined seem to be to have higher prices of transmission in the winter and reduced prices in the summertime. And we know that this seasonality is not totally pushed by human conduct. It looks like there are these other forces that are influencing this seasonal timing, these as temperature, humidity and daylight. I think it would be odd if the new coronavirus had been not likewise delicate to the seasons. If you just appeared at the essential math here, nonetheless, modifications in human conduct are likely to have a considerably bigger influence on transmission. As you pointed out, we are looking at transmission selecting up in a lot of states. But I suspect items would be even worse if it had been not for summertime.

What lessons could be gleaned from previous flu epidemics to have an understanding of what we are looking at right now with the COVID-19 pandemic?
One thing we have presently talked about is seasonal outcomes. For instance, the H1N1 flu pandemic of 2009 experienced a spring wave that died out about the summertime and then came again instead early in the tumble. The summertime weather conditions could likewise impact the transmission of COVID-19. But what we have here is a virus that is very transmissible. That helps make it hard to attract a direct comparison to any other epidemic we have experienced prior to. All past flu pandemics have been in populations with preexisting immunity, so even while it was a new virus, people today presently experienced a great deal of immunity constructed up from exposure to past flu viruses.

One more thing we are looking at is variation in the dimension and timing of COVID-19 epidemics—among not just states but countries—that can be traced to different interventions that experienced been in place in people regions. That is one thing that we also observed with the 1918 flu pandemic. We are looking at again that the timing of these waves is in all probability under our manage. It will count on how a great deal we are likely to pull again on our possess interventions.

Browse additional about the coronavirus outbreak from Scientific American here. And read coverage from our international network of journals here.